|
October 2000
TWWIIA: Ticket to funding for CILs?
Some CILs look for funding prospects in "ticket to work"
programs
Hailed
by many as the most significant disability-related legislation since the
ADA, the Ticket to Work and Work Incentives Improvement Act of 1999 (TWWIIA)
is intended to create opportunities for people with disabilities to get
off the Social Security benefits rolls and into the workforce. The law is unprecedented in its recognition of the values of consumer
choice and control-no doubt a reflection of the tireless advocacy of many
in the independent living community, among others.
Some
IL advocates believe the law is equally unprecedented in the opportunities
it brings to the doorsteps of centers for independent living. Already millions of federal grant dollars are
earmarked for several major initiatives that have sprung out of the legislation
(see page 3). A number of centers
for independent living applied for some of those dollars and await word
on who will get the nod-and the funds.
In
the meantime, one opportunity-perhaps the biggest that the new law has
to offer CILs-is waiting in the wings.
Under TWWIIA, Social Security beneficiaries will get a ticket for
employment services-one they can "spend" with any participating
employment network they choose. In
order to give consumers a wide range of choices, the law gives broad leeway
in terms of how many and what type of organizations can qualify as employment
networks.
The
regulations, which will spell out the specifics, should be released for
public comment this month. But
even without them, some advocates say the law's general requirement that
employment networks must demonstrate "substantial expertise and experience
in providing relevant employment services and supports," is perfectly
matched to CIL expertise and philosophy.
Arizona's
Susan Webb is one such advocate. CILs,
she says, are TWWIIA's best hope for moving away from old employment models.
Webb, former director of Arizona Bridge to Independent Living (ABIL),
is now founder and CEO of Webb Transitions, a company that specializes
in employment services for people with disabilities currently in the welfare
system or on private long-term disability benefits.
She's also a member of the TWWIIA advisory panel that gives guidance
to the Social Security Administration (SSA) as it rolls out the new program.
On
the financial side, Webb says, with the large target population, TWWIIA
has the potential to provide centers with a long-term funding stream. The law allows employment networks to choose
between two reimbursement options-the details of which are expected to
be included in the regs.
In
a nutshell, one option will pay off when an employment network accomplishes
certain "milestones" in the course of serving a consumer, in
addition to payments over 60 months after the consumer is employed, based
on a percentage of savings to the trust fund.
The other option doesn't pay for milestones, but pays a greater
amount over the 60 months the consumer is employed.
In either case, Webb notes that CILs who want to be employment
networks will have to figure out a way to finance the operation up front.
Finding
that initial funding will be a challenge, Webb says, one that highlights
the critical importance of good networking with foundations, employers,
financial institutions-anybody that can provide seed money.
For
CILs that are not already established in the employment services arena,
Webb says, another challenge will be to build relationships with a broad
range of businesses and organizations that have jobs and other resources
to help beneficiaries succeed in their efforts to get jobs and attain
financial independence.
"Find
out who got the benefits planning assistance and outreach grants in your
state and partner with them," she advises.
"Join chambers of commerce, human resource associations and
staffing agencies. Let them know
who you are and what you're doing."
Beyond
that, Webb notes that, so far, only a few states have opted for TWWIIA's
Medicaid buy-in provisions. She
encourages CILs to "get in the fray" to convince their state
to participate. Without the option
to keep the health care coverage Medicaid provides if they go to work,
consumers are less likely to participate in the program-which translates
to fewer people for employment networks to work with.
It's
important for CILs to be involved in the regulations process, even if
they don't plan to go for employment network status, Webb says. Not only will the regs dictate how employment
networks operate, they will dictate such things as who gets a "ticket"
and how disputes will be handled.
She
sees TWWIIA as a golden opportunity to infuse the massive service system
with the independent living philosophies and practices.
"Shame on us if we don't do everything we can to make sure
that consumers do, in fact, have choice under this new law," Webb
says. "Our philosophy-our peer mentoring approach,
our advocacy approach, the fact we do things with consumers and not to
them or for them-holds great promise for TWWIIA being successful."
Bryon
McDonald, public policy advocate for the World Institute on Disabilities,
shares Webb's enthusiasm for TWWIIA's potential to change the way people
with disabilities access and participate in the nation's employment and
health care systems. In California,
he says, CILs are partnering with other community-based organizations
to bring about "interconnected program reform."
The
California Workgroup on Work Incentives and Health Care, formed in March
2000, includes consumers, advocates and organizations that view TWWIIA
as only one part-albeit an important one-of total systems change. Noting that the Workforce Improvement Investment Act (WIIA) is being
rolled out at the same time, McDonald says the California group is working
toward reform that includes-but goes beyond-Social Security beneficiaries.
The workgroup is advocating to convince state lawmakers to create
programs to complement and supplement the new federal initiatives.
"The
conjunction of these two federal laws gives us a big opportunity,"
he says. "If we don't take advantage of that, we
are not systems advocates."
Contact Susan
Webb at 602-778-0116 or mailto:susanwebb@webbtransitions.com. To contact Bryon McDonald call 510-763-4100
or write mailto:BRYOSEMITE@aol.com.
Making $ense of Funding Opportunities
...by
Richard Petty, IL Net Director
Earlier
this year, with the help of Telesurveys Research Associates, ILRU conducted
a survey of a good number of CIL and SILC directors to get some feedback
on how we're doing in our efforts to provide information and technical
assistance to the independent living community.
We got a lot of good feedback from that effort and, in the near
future, we'll post to our website a summary of the results and how we
plan to respond to the issues it surfaced.
In
the meantime, with this issue of ILRU NetWork, we want to begin to respond
to one request that came up frequently in the survey-and one we hear more
and more often in our work with centers and statewide councils: Give us information about raising funds!
That's
a big topic for a small newsletter. Nonetheless,
we've put together some information we hope will prove useful if you're
looking for ways to enhance the income side of your ledger.
Some
of the best opportunities, it seems, come from federal agencies that are
trying to step up their programs and services for people with disabilities-especially
in the employment arena. For example,
TWWIIA-the Ticket to Work and the Work Incentives Improvement Act-is generating
a lot of interest among CILs that see an opportunity to generate income
AND further the independent living philosophy of giving consumers more
choice and control of their lives.
In
this issue we feature a basic overview of TWWIIA and the federal agencies
that are putting millions of dollars "on the street" to carry
out its intent. Yes, the deadlines
to apply for the first round of TWWIIA grants have passed.
But we think the information may
be useful to CILs that want to position themselves for the next
round.
Next,
we look at CILs that are taking advantage of other federal grants to further
their efforts to expand services to consumers.
And we feature a couple of centers that are exploring an entirely
different course-setting up commercial businesses to generate revenue. Finally, we share some of our favorite resources
for finding and applying for grant and foundation dollars.
This
is an exciting time for CILs that are looking for ways to expand their
programs and their revenues. While
we certainly have not covered all the prospects in this newsletter, we
hope it will whet your appetite for the additional information we plan
for our website, publications, teleconferences and trainings in the months
to come.
TWIIA at a glance
- TWWIIA was signed
into law in December 1999 and will be phased in nationally over a three-year
period beginning in January 2001.
- The law is intended
to make it easier for people who receive Social Security disability
benefits to enter the workforce, if they want to.
- Title I creates
the Ticket to Work and Self Sufficiency Program that allows consumers
to go to their choice of employment networks to prepare for and get
jobs. Consumer participation in the program is voluntary.
There is no limit to the number of employment networks a state
can have.
- Title II seeks to
remove disincentives that have historically kept people out of the work
force-specifically the loss of medical benefits. TWWIIA gives states the option to provide expanded Medicaid and
Medicare coverage to include more people who are working.
- Draft regulations
to implement TWWIIA were scheduled for release for public comment on
Labor Day. At this writing,
they have not been released. Many
questions about how the program will actually operate cannot be answered
until the regs are out, comments are in and final rules are published.
- Approximately eight-
to 10-million Americans currently receive benefits through the Social
Security Disability Income (SSDI) or Social Security Insurance (SSI)
programs and are potential participants in TWWIIA programs.
- The Social Security
Administration has primary responsibility for TWWIIA implementation,
administration and generating consumer awareness of its provisions.
The Health Care Financing Administration and Department of Labor,
due to their respective responsibilities for health care benefits and
employment programs, are also major players in TWWIIA implementation.
- A 12-member advisory
panel advises SSA on all aspects of TWWIIA implementation.
By law, at least half of the members must be people with disabilities,
with preference given to current or former Social Security beneficiaries. Panelists represent the interests of consumers, service providers,
employers and employees. To
communicate with members, send e-mail to mailto:TWWIIAPanel@SSA.gov.
Federal grants support
TWWIIA rollout
While
the Social Security Administration has primary responsibility to implement
TWWIIA, the Health Care Financing Administration and Department of Labor
are also charged with helping to assure the initiative's success. All three agencies are funding grant programs
to address various aspects of the law's requirements. The following is an "in a nutshell" summary of the grants
and their status as this newsletter goes to press. (Editor's Note: Keep an eye on the ILRU website—www.ilru.org—for
updates.)
Work
Incentive Grants
Agency:
Employment and Training Administration, Dept. of Labor (ETA/DOL)
Purpose: To develop or strengthen the capacity of the
"One-Stop" employment system to provide effective and meaningful
services to people with disabilities.
Available Funds: $20 million in 20-40 grant
awards ranging from $500,000-$1.5 million
Eligible Applicants: CILs are specifically named
in a list of state and/or local public and private entities considered
eligible to apply for grant funds. DOL
strongly encourages collaborative efforts.
If an applicant consortium does not include CILs, the applicant
is instructed to describe how it will include them in grant activities.
Deadline: August 1, 2000 (Note: While the application deadline has passed,
there is speculation that the process could be re-opened in the event
not enough applications were received or approved.)
Status: At this writing, grant award announcements
are pending.
Benefits
Planning, Assistance and Outreach Program
Agency: Social Security Administration (SSA)
Purpose: To inform consumers about work incentives programs
and provide benefits planning and assistance (awardees are required to
select "benefits specialists" to conduct outreach and benefits
counseling). Projects that are
funded are also required to collect and report data pertaining to the
effort.
Available Funds: $23 million issued through
cooperative agreements ranging from $50,000-$300,000
Eligible Applicants: CILs are specifically named
in a list of potential recipients the SSA Commissioner could determine
qualified to perform the activities, including public, private, profit
and non-profit agencies or organizations within "targeted geographic"
areas.
Deadline: July 31, 2000 (Note: While the deadline
has passed, SSA is expected to solicit more applications next year.)
Status: At this writing, cooperative agreements are
pending.
Medicaid
Infrastructure Grant Program to Support the
Competitive Employment of People with Disabilities
Agency: Health Care Financing Administration (HCFA),
Dept. of Health and Human Services
Purpose: To build and strengthen state Medicaid systems'
ability to support people with disabilities in their efforts to get and
keep jobs.
Available Funds: $20 million in the first
grant year with annual increases so that fifth-year funding will total
$150 million. Eligible states
can get up to $1.25 million in the first grant year and $1.5 million in
subsequent years. (Note: While all states are eligible to apply for grants, the amount and
duration of funds they can receive is directly related to their capacity
to provide comprehensive, statewide personal assistance services in accordance
with specific criteria laid out in the funding notice. The PAS requirement may provide CILs with opportunities
to generate income by working with the state Medicaid agency to build
or maintain comprehensive, statewide services.)
Eligible Applicants: The Single State Medicaid
Agency or any other state agency "in partnership, agreement and active
participation with the state Medicaid agency."
Deadline: July 31, 2000 (Note: New funding notices will be published annually
for four years.)
Status: The announcement of the first round of awards
is expected in October 2000.
Demonstration
to Maintain Independence and Employment
Agency: Health Care Financing Administration (HCFA)
Purpose: To extend Medicaid equivalent benefits and
services to workers who are not yet disabled enough to qualify for Medicaid
or Social Security benefits under current rules, but whose potentially
severe physical or mental impairments are likely to lead to disability.
Available Funds: $250 million overall to
be awarded in six-year grants.
Eligible Applicants: The Single State Medicaid
Agency. (Note: Independent living advocates that work closely
with their state Medicaid agencies believe there is an opportunity to
collaborate in the demonstration.)
Deadline: August 7, 2000 (Note: There is speculation the notice will be released
again in the near future.)
Status: Demonstration grant recipients were not announced
at this writing.
For More Information
About These Federal Grants
Work Incentive Grants-www.wdsc.org/disability/htmldocs/work_incentives_sga.html
Benefits Planning and Outreach-www.ssa.gov/work/ServiceProviders/congrant2.html
Medicaid Infrastructure Grants-www.hcfa.gov/medicaid/twwiia/advocacy.htm
Demonstration to Maintain Independence and Employment-http://www.hcfa.gov/medicaid/twwiia/independ.htm
NOTE THE DATE! DETAILS COMING SOON!
The IL Net Presents--Entrepreneurialism in CILs: For Profit and Fee-for-Service
Opportunities
March 5-7, 2001
Kansas City, MO
For more information:
Kristy Langbehn 703-525-4153 (TTY) 703-525-3409 (Fax)
HCFA DME demo tests consumer control
A few weeks ago, the Health Care Financing Administration (HCFA) announced
the selection of four local centers for independent living to help the
federal agency determine ways to give Medicare recipients more choice
and control when they buy wheelchairs and related equipment.
HCFA gave each center $150,000 for the first year of a four-year
"Consumer-Directed Durable Medical Equipment (CD-DME) Demonstration
Project."
Oklahoma's Ability Resources, Inc., is one of the four centers. Director
Carla Lawson says her center's interest in the project has more to do
with the opportunity than the money it brings in. The demonstration sites
will test ways to put consumers in charge of the whole wheelchair-buying
process-from prescription, to selection, fitting and, finally, submitting
their own payment forms. The main
role of the CILs in the project is to educate consumers about the process
and the products so they can make informed decisions about the equipment
that will best meet their needs.
In
conjunction with the demonstration projects, HCFA will try out a change
in the process by which wheelchair purchases are authorized. A Durable Medical Equipment Regional Carrier (DMERC) will be assigned
to work with the four CILs to preauthorize purchases, allowing consumers
to know up front what HCFA will pay for their wheelchairs. As opposed to the current system, where the
authorization comes after the equipment is ordered, Lawson says the new
process will strengthen consumers' negotiations with equipment providers.
The
CILs won't actually serve consumers until the second year of the project. Year one, Lawson says, will be devoted to a
multitude of tasks including working up service protocols, creating marketing
materials, developing quality assurance guidelines, training staff and
more.
The
most challenging task will likely be figuring out how to make services
to consumers "budget neutral" as required by grant rules. HCFA won't pay CILs for the services they provide
individual consumers, Lawson says, "so our challenge is to see how
we can provide the service and still have a revenue stream."
Lawson
thinks that Medicaid home and community-based waivers may hold some prospect
for that. She says the center
is also exploring the possibility of setting up consultation fees for
things like reviewing wheelchair prescriptions for HMOs as a source of
income.
Lawson
says she doesn't see how the grant will create any immediate new financial
opportunities for CILs-HCFA doesn't plan to expand the demonstration. And, she says, it's way too early to tell if
this activity will ever have any potential to generate significant income. Nonetheless, she is glad to participate.
"We
see it as a fantastic opportunity," Lawson says. "If we can possibly make a wheelchair acquisition a little
bit easier on consumers and see them in the right chair with the right
tires and the right fit-it would be something we would be proud to say
we were involved with."
In
addition to the Oklahoma CIL, HCFA awarded demonstration funds to Maine's
Alpha One Center for Independent Living, Massachusetts' Center for Living
and Working and the Center for Independent Living of Southwest Pennsylvania.
Contact
Carla Lawson by sending e-mail to mailto:ar@cottagesoft.com
or calling 918-592-1235.
Hot Links to Grant
and Foundation Information
cybergrants.com - http://www.cybergrants.com/
Free to non-profits, this website allows users to search for foundations,
develop proposals and submit them online.
Environmental
Protection Agency - www.epa.gov/seahome/grants/src/msieopen.htm
This site features a great interactive proposal writing tutorial
with a lot of good tips, mock grant writing activity and an excellent
glossary. Most of the links are
related to EPA issues, but the generic information should be useful to
anyone.
Grant Proposal.com
- www.grantproposal.com
Free information for non-profit grant writers at all skill levels.
The site contains advice from funders, a bunch of tips and tricks-even
a listing of active verbs to perk up grant applications.
The Foundation Center
- fdncenter.org/index.html
The center offers a truckload of information on grant making organizations.
You can sign up for free newsletters including The Philanthropy
News Digest and the weekly RFP
Bulletin. Check out the Grant
Maker Websites for links to foundations in every state.
The Grantsmanship Center
- www.tgci.com
Our favorite spot on this site is a direct link to "today's"
Federal Register. Click on "federal
government" from the home page and you'll find it.
You can also order low-cost publications on a variety of topics
or learn about training opportunities.
Disability Funding
News - www.cdpublications.com/funding/dfn.htm
There's not a lot of information on this site beyond how to subscribe
for the monthly Disability Funding News (print or electronic version)
that provides details on public and private funding opportunities for
a wide range of disability-related programs.
A 12-month, prepaid subscription is $299.
Innovation Network,
Inc. (InnoNet) - www.innonet.org
The site contains workstations to develop fundraising action plans
and grant applications--free if you register as a user.
Grant Update! - http://www.arcpro.net/grantupdate
This is a good source for a lot of free information about writing
proposals as well as information on new funding opportunities. It has a good links section, too. Some features are available to members only. They're currently having a "sale"
on annual membership for $39.95.
About.com - http://www.nonprofit.about.com/careers/nonprofit
This website has information on hundreds of topics and a good section
about grants on its non-profits pages.
PWI Joins CILs and Business Community
Long
before there were "tickets" for employment services or "One-Stop" employment centers-well
before there were centers for independent living-there was Projects With
Industry (PWI). This federal program
was established in 1968 as part of the Rehabilitation Act. PWI's mission is to create more job and career
opportunities for people with disabilities by strengthening linkages between
the public vocational rehabilitation program and private industry. The work is carried out by grantees that, in
addition to building relationships in the business community, provide
an array of support services to job seekers with disabilities.
A broad
range of agencies and organizations-including centers for independent
living-are potentially eligible for PWI funds.
But until relatively recently, CILs have not been part of the PWI
picture.
Ten
years ago, the National Center for Disability Services-an organization
that promotes employment for people with disabilities-had occasion to
work with a CIL on a national project.
Judy Young, PWI director, recalls it was her first real exposure
to the independent living philosophy.
Through that experience, Young remembers, "I learned that
employment programs fit very nicely with the IL movement because CILs
provide support services that can assist a person in getting and maintaining
employment. IL services like housing
assistance, personal assistance services, independent living skills training-all
are really needed by people seeking employment."
Three
years later, PWI released a new series of grants and Young was ready to
act on her revelation. She rounded
up seven CILs in as many states to join NCDS in a proposal.
Kentucky's
Center for Accessible Living (CAL) was one of the CILs that joined the
effort and subsequently became a subcontractor when NCDS got the PWI grant. Jan Day, the center's executive director, remembers
learning about PWI at the very first National Council on Independent Living
(NCIL) meeting she attended.
"At
that same time," Day says, "we were taking a look at who we
were. We had some good ties with
Kentucky VR and it all just evolved.
We liked the idea of an employment program being within a CIL-especially
so soon after the signing of ADA and its focus on employment. We felt that by collaborating-and with our experience with disability-we
could assist people with disabilities to achieve their employment career
goals."
Day
says PWI funds, combined with other dollars from various grants, allows
CAL to provide a more complete array of services to consumers-services
the center would not be able to provide otherwise.
Additionally, by providing employment services, she says the CIL
has attracted a whole new sector of people with disabilities and increased
participation in other center services.
"They come in for a job, but we discover they need assistance
with things like housing, attendant care or peer counseling. Our overall number of people served has gone
up drastically."
The
other big payoff, from her perspective, comes from heightened visibility
in the business community. The
grant's requirement to have a business advisory council put the center
in touch with a number of "big players" who didn't know anything
about independent living issues previously.
The
center's increased visibility with businesses and employers, Day says,
has increased the CIL's advocacy activities-and bank account-in a big
way. For example, she says, CAL recently received
$1.2 million for personal assistance services thanks, in large part, to
the business advisory council's support and advocacy for it.
In
addition to the Kentucky CIL, NCDS has PWI subcontracts with centers in
Alabama, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Missouri and Texas. "In general," Judy Young says, "I
think what most of the sites have gained is a higher degree of visibility
from our relationship. As a result,
some are able to secure funds from other than RSA, they're interacting
with the employment community and quite a few have successful media coverage-all
of which serves to bring in more people with disabilities and more money.
I think PWI is particularly appropriate for CILs that set their
sights on expansion."
The
next PWI grant announcement is expected within the next few months. CILs are eligible to apply for funds, however,
Young notes that many individual centers will find it difficult to serve
enough people through the program to qualify for even the minimum level
of funding. In those cases, she
advises, centers might benefit from creating partnerships with other centers
or organizations to apply for PWI funds.
For
more information about the National Center for Disability Services' Project
With Industry activities, contact Judy Young at mailto:young@business-disability.com or 516-465-1491.
Contact Jan Day at mailto:janday@callou.win.net
or 502-589-6620.
STW: Another Opportunity?
The Federal Departments of Education and Labor recently
distributed more than $20 million among 10 states participating in the
School-to-Work (STW) transition initiative. The funds are intended to
help these states maintain their STW projects after their initial five-year
grants end.
CILs in these states may want to check in with their
STW representatives to learn about opportunities to tap into those funds.
The states are California, Connecticut, Louisiana, Minnesota, Missouri,
Nevada, New Mexico, Rhode Island, Tennessee and Texas.
For more information go to the STW website: http://www.stw.ed.gov/
“Social entrepreneurialism” in the Aloha State
Hawaii center gaining valuable insight from business
experiences
About five years ago, the Hawaii Centers for Independent
Living (HCIL) board and staff took a good hard look at its financial situation
and didn't like the picture. The entire state was in an economic slump
brought on by drastically decreased tourist revenues resulting from Desert
Storm. As state coffers dwindled, many state agencies experienced big
budget cuts-some as much as 35 percent. Many nonprofits that relied solely
on state dollars were forced to close their doors.
With finite Title VII dollars and one relatively small
United Way grant, HCIL was having a tough time meeting a growing demand
for services. With approximately 96 percent of its budget restricted by
the requirements of its two major funding sources, the center was also
looking for ways to bring in funds that didn't have so many strings attached.
A golf tournament fundraiser netted HCIL some $5,000
dollars, a respectable sum. But, HCIL director Mark Obatake says the experience
caused the board and staff to realize that the return on special events
would not be enough in light of the expense and intensive effort it takes
to put them together.
Looking for other options, they explored what Obatake
calls a "social-entrepreneurial model" of raising revenue-one
he describes as "dovetailing a business provision with a mission
statement." It didn't take them long to find a promising prospect.
Hawaii businesses were woefully behind in complying with
the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) accessibility requirements and
many were struggling with what to do and how to do it, Obatake says. With
an abundance of ADA information and experience, HCIL had a marketable
product. Access Aloha, Inc.-an ADA consulting firm-became the CIL's first
venture into the commercial business world.
The company was set up to operate totally separate from
the CIL. The center hired a staff person to run it and charged the fledgling
company for rent and use of office equipment. We wanted to keep the business
at arm's length," Obatake says. We weren't involved in supervision
or business operations.
Within a year and a half, the company was in the black.
That was pretty unusual," Obatake says. Most new, small companies
don't see profits for two or three years.
But, the success was short-lived. The staff person left
to have a baby and the business community was getting more educated about
ADA and less in need of Aloha's services. The one-two punch was too much
for the fledgling business, but not for HCIL's entrepreneurial spirit.
"We were on the right track," Obatake says.
The center reviewed its strengths, its mission-and at
some point its information and referral logs. Those logs revealed as many
as 15 calls a week-from travelers all over the world-looking for information
about accessible transportation to and lodging in Hawaii.
We started to ask around, we called travel agencies,"
Obatake recalls, "and learned that they didn't have good understanding
of access and didn't really give a rip about disabilities. So we decided
if nobody else was doing it, maybe we should. We used the same corporate
shell, redefined the work and created Access Aloha Travel, Inc."
This time, HCIL brought in a staff person with years
of experience in the travel industry-HCIL taught her about accommodations.
"We didn't want to have to learn the complexities of the travel trade,"
Obatake says.
Once again, the combination worked-it didn't take long
for the company to become profitable.And, once again, changes in the industry
caused the CIL to reconsider its stake in the company." The travel
industry is a strange business and the net margin is very small,"
Obatake says."While it was carrying out a mission, it wasn't raising
the kinds of dollars that we need."
The center sold the business to the travel agent. In
addition to the revenue from the sale, the center still rents space to
the business and gets the income from that.
Neither venture has created the long-term funding stream
HCIL envisioned, but Obatake says both have given the center important
perspective in terms of the value of its services and their potential
to raise revenue. "We have restructured our services to be more in
line with fee-based operations," Obatake says, noting the center
has raised more than $30,000 in fees providing services based on core
IL services such as home assessments, consultation to home health care
agencies, ADA training and more.
And while these fees come from sources other than center
consumers, Obatake views looking at services in terms of their value as
a consumer benefit. Despite the emphasis on consumer choice and control,
he says, the reality is that "we are still operating in a system
where rehab service providers control the dollars."
When consumers do control their own service dollars,
the stream of resources will change. When consumers get control of their
dollars are they going to spend it with you?" he asks. If they're
not paying you for the services now, how do you know they will later?
I couldn't answer that question before we looked at our services in a
more businesslike way. I can now.
Contact Mark Obatake at 808-522-5400 or mailto:mobatake@diverseabilities.org.
Texas CIL has “designs” on future funding
What started as an effort to improve its own public image
launched the Austin Resource Center for Independent Living (ARCIL) into
the commercial business world. ARCIL Graphics is a one-man, full-service
design and desktop publishing operation located in Austin, Texas.
From a state-of-the-art studio housed in ARCIL's headquarters,
Earl Chandler designs logos, newsletters, brochures and more for a growing
number of clients. Some of them, such as the Association of Programs for
Rural Independent Living (APRIL) and Texas Association of Centers for
Independent Living (TACIL) are part of the IL community. Word of mouth
advertising is bringing in businesses that have nothing to do with disabilities
or advocacy-a local food distributor is a recent example.
Chandler joined the ARCIL staff in 1988 as an administrator.
Shortly thereafter, the CIL started beefing up its arsenal of computers,
which made it easy for program staff to develop their own public information
materials. According to Jack Stratton, deputy director, the resulting
publication frenzy lacked coordination and caused the center to experience
a kind of identity crisis-materials were not consistent in message or
appearance. This created problems for a center trying to establish a strong
image with the public and existing and potential funding sources. Furthermore,
it was getting expensive to produce materials using outside sources.
Their solution? Centralize the publication function and
do the design and printing in-house. Due to his interest and emerging
talent as a graphic designer, Chandler was tapped for the responsibility.
He went back to college for formal training and earned a commercial art
degree.
At first, Chandler focused on ARCIL's needs and developed
a unified family of publications reflecting a new agency image. At the
same time-perhaps helped along by its spiffed up image-ARCIL started getting
more grants and offering additional programs and services. Each new program
came with its own publication needs-for brochures, reports, manuals and
the like. The graphics shop quickly earned its keep.
It wasn't until 1996 that the CIL started to think about
the function as a potential moneymaker. ARCIL Graphics was created that
year and Chandler started taking in a few outside jobs to test the waters.
To this point, he says, ARCIL has done little to promote the business,
preferring to grow it slowly and build a solid foundation. Even so, he
adds, business is gradually growing and the company has definite potential
to turn a profit.
Since its inception, ARCIL Graphics has operated within
the center's program budget. Therefore, any revenue the company generates
is considered program revenue and must be treated as such. Between the
savings ARCIL realizes by doing its own design and printing and the modest
income it's generating, ARCIL graphics pays for itself.
What doesn't show up on the center's ledgers is the value
the graphics operation brings to the community. Chandler is still in touch
with the college he attended and has taken in several student interns-some
of them students with disabilities. It gives students a chance to apply
what they're learning and build their portfolios," Chandler says,
"and gives ARCIL the chance to give something back to the community."
Mary Ann Hernandez, ARCIL's chief financial officer,
says the CIL has hopes of "spinning off" the design business
and creating an independent corporation that can bring in dollars that
are not restricted by program requirements. Toward that end, Hernandez
says, the center is developing a business plan and beginning to look for
foundation money or other outside funds that could support the business
start-up.
Except for its own business needs nearly a decade ago,
ARCIL might have never come up with the idea to start a graphics design
company. While it's not the kind of business that every CIL can or would
want to pursue, Stratton and Chandler believe some CILs might find it
worth trying.
First, they say, it’s important to know the market
for such services in individual communities. Austin, Chandler says, is
almost saturated with similar companies and area colleges are producing
a lot of graphic artists who want to stay and work there. CILs in smaller
communities might have an easier time finding a niche in a market where
there are fewer companies providing the same service.
If the market is right, the next challenge would probably
be financing the necessary equipment. It doesn’t come cheap. ARCIL
Graphics owns some of its own equipment but leases the high-powered printer
that allows Chandler to produce full-color publications. “It takes
a lot of printing to justify the expense,” Chandler says.
“Then,” Stratton says, “you have to
have the person who has the education and experience in graphics production.
This isn’t something that just anybody in the center can do.”
Chandler agrees, and adds there is quite a bit to learn
on the business side of the operation, as well. “We had to learn
how much to charge for services, what needed to be in our contracts–things
you don’t learn in art school.”
For more information, call Earl Chandler at ARCIL Graphics
at 512-832-6349 or send e-mail to mailto:arcil@bga.com
NetNotes
Don't forget you can find this and all past issues of
ILRU NetWork online at http://www.ilru.org/. You'll find it under the
Independent Living heading. With most issues, you'll find links to related
information and resources we just couldn't fit in the newsletter.
In this issue's introductory article, Richard Petty,
IL Net director, mentions a recent survey of CIL and SILC directors to
determine awareness of-and satisfaction with-ILRU services. A full summary
of the findings is posted on our website along with this issue of the
newsletter. Through the survey, we got a lot of reinforcement for many
of the things we're doing-and we like that. Even better, survey participants
revealed some activities we can strengthen. We've already started to work
on those and we'll report on our progress in future newsletters and on
the website. If you have comments on the survey results or more ideas
for ways we can improve, feel free to use the link on the website to send
them our way. Or call, write or fax using the information in the masthead
below.
The newest addition to the ILRU Bookshelf series—Bobby
Silverstein's three-part Congressional Insider's Guide—is getting rave
reviews! As you may know, Silverstein spent many years as a key Congressional
staffer who was instrumental in the passage of important disability legislation.
Now director of the Center for the Study and Advancement of Disability
Policy, Silverstein shares a wealth of information about participating
in all aspects of the legislative process in this series of publications.
For more information, contact Carri George, ILRU publications coordinator,
at 713-520-0232 or mailto:cgeorge@bcm.tmc.edu.
|